November 12, 2025

Electric Fire vs Gas Fireplace: Cost, Efficiency & Real Heat Compared

Torn between the cosy glow of a gas fire and the plug-and-play charm of an electric one?
Short answer: Electric fires win for ease, safety, and style—especially in modern Electric Fire Suites—while gas still rules for authentic warmth.
Stick around to see which truly sparks joy (and savings) in your home.

Cost and Installation Comparison

When choosing a new fire, the first big question isn’t usually about heat—it’s about money and hassle. Installation can make or break your budget, so it’s worth knowing what you’re really signing up for.

Upfront Purchase and Installation Costs

Gas: Need for Flue/Ventilation, Gas Line Installation, and Professional Labour

Gas fireplaces bring the real flame magic, but they don’t come cheap.
You’ll need a Gas Safe registered engineer, proper ventilation, and sometimes a new gas line. That can mean chasing walls, fitting flues, and plenty of dust before the first spark even flickers.

If your home doesn’t already have a gas connection, the bill quickly rises.
So while the end result is undeniably stunning, it’s fair to say gas fires demand both commitment and cash up front.

Electric: Simple Plug-and-Play or Easy Hardwiring

Now, compare that to an electric fire. Most of them are gloriously simple—plug in, switch on, instant glow.
Even inset or wall-mounted models are straightforward, usually needing nothing more than a nearby socket or light wiring from an electrician.

That’s why electric fires are so popular for Electric Fire Suites—no flues, no fuss, and you can have one glowing away in a weekend.
They’re also renter-friendly and perfect for homes without a gas supply.

Running and Fuel Costs Over Time

Here’s where things get interesting. Electricity costs more per kilowatt-hour than gas, but electric fires are nearly 100% efficient—every bit of energy becomes heat.

Gas fires, on the other hand, lose some warmth up the chimney, though the fuel itself is cheaper.
So if you love running your fire for hours every night, gas usually wins on running costs.

But for shorter bursts—say, a quick heat-up while watching telly—electric is more cost-effective.
Add smart plugs or off-peak electricity tariffs, and the difference narrows even more.

Safety, Maintenance, and Heat Output

Safety, maintenance, and performance all play a part in choosing your perfect fire. Here’s where each type really shows its personality.

Authenticity and Aesthetic Experience

Gas: The Benefit of a Real, Moving Flame

Nothing beats the hypnotic dance of a real flame. It’s the heart and soul of a gas fire.
The gentle crackle, the instant warmth—it’s as close as you can get to a traditional log burner without chopping wood.

However, there’s a catch: that realism needs proper ventilation and a bit of annual TLC.
A yearly service keeps it safe and burning efficiently, so factor that into the cost of ownership.

Electric: The Trade-Off for Convenience and Control (Flame Effects)

Electric fires have come a long way since the plastic logs of the past.
Modern LED and holographic displays look surprisingly convincing—and best of all, you can enjoy the flame effect without any heat at all.

Picture a warm orange glow on a summer evening, just for ambience.
No gas lines, no smoke, and you can change the colour, brightness, or flame speed with a remote.
It’s not quite a real flame, but it’s definitely high on charm and convenience.

Heat Capacity and Efficiency

Gas: Higher BTU Output as a Primary Heat Source

If you need serious warmth—say, heating up a chilly living room on a frosty night—a gas fire delivers.
Most models produce between 3.5 and 5 kW of heat, making them great as a primary heat source.

They heat quickly and can easily handle bigger rooms.
Just remember, some of that energy escapes through the flue, so you’re not getting every bit of heat you’re paying for.

Electric: Lower Output for Zone Heating

Electric fires typically max out around 2 kW, so they’re best for zone heating—warming a specific space rather than the whole house.
Perfect for a snug, a bedroom, or that corner of the living room where you curl up with a book.

They’re also nearly 100% efficient at point of use—no flue, no loss.
You get instant warmth, total control, and a predictable running cost.

Safety and Indoor Air Quality

Gas: Risk of Carbon Monoxide (CO) and Need for Annual Servicing

Gas fires are safe when properly looked after—but they do come with responsibilities.
You’ll need annual servicing from a Gas Safe engineer to prevent carbon monoxide leaks and ensure everything’s venting correctly.

A good CO detector is essential, and it’s wise to keep an eye on airflow.
Think of it as owning a high-performance car—it runs beautifully when maintained, but neglect it and problems can creep in.

Electric: Cool-to-the-Touch and Zero Emissions

Electric fires are the low-maintenance option.
No fumes, no emissions, and cool exteriors make them ideal for homes with kids or pets.

There’s nothing to vent or service—just keep the display dust-free and you’re good to go.
Plus, since they don’t actually burn anything, there’s no risk of carbon monoxide or soot build-up.
Clean, safe, and refreshingly simple.

Conclusion: Which Fireplace is Right for You?

So, which one deserves a spot in your home?

If you love the flicker of a real flame, crave that deep, radiant warmth, and don’t mind a little upkeep—a gas fire is your match.
They’re ideal for bigger rooms or anyone who wants a true, traditional feel.

But if you prefer simplicity, safety, and effortless style, go for an electric fire.
They’re brilliant for Electric Fire Suites, smaller spaces, or anyone who wants to enjoy a cosy glow without the maintenance.

In short:

Gas fires = more heat and realism.
Electric fires = more convenience and control.

And with the UK’s energy mix becoming greener each year, electric fires are growing ever more appealing for the eco-conscious homeowner.

Whichever you choose, the right fire will add warmth, comfort, and character to your home—because sometimes, happiness really does start with a good flame.

Other content we think you'll love

Previous article Do Electric Fireplaces Really Heat a Room? Efficiency Explained

Next article Why Your Fireplace Smells Like Burning Plastic (and What to Do About It)