Natural Gas Fire Pit vs Propane: Which Fuel is Right for You?
Can’t decide between natural gas or propane for your fire pit or fire table? Quick answer: natural gas is cheaper and low-maintenance, propane is hotter and portable. But don’t light the match just yet—we’re breaking down the heat, hassle, and hidden costs so your backyard vibes stay fire, not fiasco.
Natural Gas Fire Pits: Pros and Cons
Let’s start with natural gas. It’s the stay-at-home type—reliable, steady, and always ready for a cosy evening in.
Perfect if your outdoor space is a well-planned haven rather than a constantly shifting experiment.
Advantages:
Lower fuel costs (generally)
Natural gas is typically the more budget-friendly option over time. If your home already has a gas connection, you’re laughing.
There’s no need to keep buying replacement tanks or trekking to the shop when you run out mid-party.
For anyone who uses their fire pit regularly, those little savings add up fast.
Continuous supply from gas line
The best thing about natural gas? It never runs out.
You get an uninterrupted fuel source straight from the mains. One connection and you’re sorted—no storage, no panic refills, no running on empty.
Just flick it on and enjoy the glow.
Disadvantages:
Requires gas line installation
If your garden doesn't already have a gas line near your seating area, you’ll need to have one installed.
This means a bit of groundwork—literally. You might have to dig a trench and call in the pros.
It’s a one-time job, but it can bump up your upfront costs.
Less portable
Once your fire table or pit is plumbed into the gas line, that’s its forever home.
You won’t be dragging it down to the bottom of the garden or packing it for a camping trip. If you're someone who likes to mix up your layout or move things about seasonally, this setup isn’t for you.
Propane Fire Pits: Pros and Cons
Now, propane. It’s the adventurous sibling—always ready to go, whether that’s to the beach, a barbecue, or just the far side of the patio.
Ideal for spontaneous gatherings or renters who don’t want to commit to permanent fixtures.
Advantages:
Portability and flexibility
With propane, your fire pit can follow the fun.
Whether you're entertaining on the deck, relaxing by the shed, or tailgating at a festival, it comes with you. No digging, no pipes, just pick it up and plop it where the party is.
It’s outdoor entertaining on your own terms.
Easy to set up
Propane pits are the plug-and-play option of the fire world. No need for a professional or a lengthy setup.
Attach the tank, click the ignition, and you've got flames.
It’s perfect for anyone who prefers simplicity over setup instructions.
Disadvantages:
Higher fuel costs (propane tanks)
The flip side? Those propane tanks don’t come cheap.
Each refill is more expensive per unit than natural gas, and if you’re using your fire pit often, you’ll feel it in your wallet.
It’s the price you pay for portability and convenience.
Requires tank refills
There’s nothing like the disappointment of running out of fuel mid-toast.
Propane users need to keep an eye on their tank levels—and ideally keep a spare on standby. If you forget, it’s an early night for everyone.
There’s a little more hands-on management involved.
Key Differences: Natural Gas vs. Propane
Here’s where we stack them side by side—the big differences that will likely tip the scales for you.
Fuel Supply and Costs:
Gas line vs. propane tanks
Natural gas is piped straight from your home’s gas line, giving you a constant supply.
Propane is tank-based—you’ll need to connect it manually and replace or refill it regularly. It’s less effort once set up with gas, but propane offers more freedom in return.
Cost per unit of fuel
Natural gas wins this round. It’s consistently cheaper per unit, and you won’t need to keep buying new tanks.
Propane, while convenient, is more expensive in the long run—especially for frequent use.
Portability and Convenience:
Fixed installation vs. portability
If you want a permanent feature in your garden, natural gas gives you that seamless, built-in look.
If you prefer something you can move with the seasons—or take on a weekend break—propane is your go-to. It’s all about how you like to live outdoors.
Choosing the Right Option for Your Needs
So which fuel fits your lifestyle? Let’s break it down.
Space and Usage:
Indoor vs. outdoor use
Both fuels are designed for outdoor use—no smoky living rooms here!
That said, fire tables can work well in covered areas like patios or pergolas (with proper ventilation). Propane gives you more options if your space changes or doubles as a party venue.
Natural gas suits a more permanent outdoor living area.
Frequency of use
Planning to use your fire pit every weekend? Natural gas will save you money and stress over time.
Only lighting it up now and then? Propane might be more practical, even if it costs a bit more per use.
It’s all about how often you fire things up.
Gas Line Access and Installation:
Availability of natural gas line
If your home already uses gas for cooking or heating, you may be able to extend that line outdoors.
If not, installation will be a bigger task—but it could still be worth it in the long term.
Installation costs
Propane wins on setup cost. You’ll only need the pit and a tank, and you’re off to the races.
Natural gas needs professional installation, which can set you back a few hundred pounds—but it pays off over time if you use your fire pit regularly.
Conclusion
So, what’s the verdict in the great natural gas fire pit vs propane debate?
Go for natural gas if you want low-cost fuel, zero refills, and a permanent fire feature that’s always ready to glow. It's best for regular use and those who like their garden setup just so.
Choose propane if you love flexibility, need more heat, or like to move your fire pit to match your mood. It’s the perfect choice for renters, travellers, or anyone who values freedom over fixtures.
Whichever fuel you choose, your fire table or pit is sure to bring warmth, charm, and maybe even a few burnt marshmallows to your outdoor space.
Other content we think you'll love
- Fire Table: Gas vs Bioethanol vs Wood Burning – Which Is Best for You?
- Gas Fire Pit: Glass or Lava Rock? Which One is Right for You?
- Gas Fire Pit: Rocks or Glass – Which Should You Choose?
- Gas Fire Pits vs Wood Fire Pits: Which One Is Right for You?
- Propane, Butane or Natural Gas Fire Table: Which One Should You Choose?
- What Gas Does a Fire Pit Use?
- What is a Natural Gas Fire Pit? Your Ultimate Guide to This Convenient Outdoor Feature
- What Is a Propane Fire Table? The Ultimate Guide to Outdoor Flame
- Why Lava Rocks Are a Must-Have for Your Fire Pit
- What Gas Should You Use for Your Fire Pit Table?